PERC Examiner Holds No Breach of Duty of Fair Representation by King County Metro in Withdrawing Grievances

By Jim Cline and Abagail Klonsinski

In King County Metro, Examiner Todd granted summary judgment for the Union, finding that the Union did not breach their duty of fair representation (DFR) when it withdrew his grievance from arbitration. The Complainant ultimately failed to produce evidence which showed the Union had acted in an arbitrary manner or bad faith when making their decision, so summary judgment was appropriate in favor of the Union.

[Read more…]

Where the Sun Don’t Shine: Spokane County Can’t Require Unions to Agree to Public Negotiations

By James Cline and Stephen Hatton

In Spokane County, Decision 13435 (PECB, 2021), PERC Hearing Examiner Erin Slone-Gomez found that the County had violated its duty to bargain in good faith by insisting their negotiation sessions with the Corrections Union be open to the public. She found ground rules for negotiations to be a permissive subject of bargaining.

[Read more…]

BREAKING NEWS: Cline and Associates to Become Cline & Casillas!

Jim Cline and Chris Casillas opened the Firm’s Annual Client Training Seminar to announce that they are launching a new partnership. [Read more…]

Cline & Associates Welcomes Attorney, Erica Shelley Nelson

ESN FinalCline & Associates welcomes new attorney, Erica Shelley Nelson. Erica received her B.A. in Political Science from Western Washington University in June 2001. She graduated from Gonzaga Law School in 2005, and participated as a member of Gonzaga’s National Trial Team. [Read more…]

The Availability of Other Options besides Resignation is Not Dispositive in a Wrongful Constructive Discharge Claim

By Anthony Rice

In Barnett v. Sequim Valley Ranch, the court upheld a $427,230 jury award for the plaintiffs and former employees of Sequim Valley Ranch. The court held that the plaintiffs’ constructive, wrongful discharge suit was timely filed, and the trial court properly instructed the jury on the elements of a wrongful constructive discharge claim.

[Read more…]

Washington Appeals Court Rules that Proper Vision is a Bona Fide Occupational Qualification for Operating Snow Plows with a CDL

By Anthony Rice

In Fey v. Community Colleges of Spokane, the court reversed a $58,000 judgment for the plaintiff Mark Fey, a grounds keeper at Spokane Community College, for the college’s failure to accommodate Fey’s disability. The court ruled that the college is not liable because they were not required to modify the essential functions of a job to accommodate Fey’s terrible vision. [Read more…]

Legal Woes Continue to Plague Mountlake Terrace Police Department

By Jim Cline

The legal woes and legal costs continue to compound for the beleaguered Mountlake Terrace Police Department and its City management team.  Within weeks of being ordered by an arbitrator to reinstate police officer Tam Guthrie, the City has now been forced to pay out for the wrongful discharge of a former police secretary, Martha Karl.

[Read more…]

Hearing Examiner Rules that Enumerated Rights in Collective Bargaining are Permissive Subjects of Bargaining

By Rick Gautschi

 

In City of Bellevue, Decision 11435 (PECB, 2012) the union alleged that the employer had committed two unfair labor practices in the collective bargaining process.  First, the employer proposed maintaining a “management rights” provision that listed enumerated rights in the existing collective bargaining agreement.  When the union proposed deleting the provision, over the union’s objection, the employer insisted on including the provision and on certifying the enumerated items to interest arbitration.  Second, the employer bargained to impasse and sought interest arbitration of an attorneys’ fees provision in existing grievance procedure language. [Read more…]